Compare hire purchase and finance lease for business assets — ownership, tax treatment, balance sheet impact, and monthly cost in the UK.
Not sure which is right? Check eligibility for both in 2 minutes.
Check EligibilityHire purchase is a form of asset finance where you pay for an asset in instalments over an agreed term, at the end of which legal title passes to you. You hire the asset during the repayment period — the finance company retains ownership until the final payment and an option fee (typically £1 to £200) are made. From day one, however, you have full use of the asset and take responsibility for its maintenance, insurance, and ongoing condition.
The finance company funds the full cost of the asset (minus any deposit, usually 10-20%) and charges interest on the outstanding balance over the agreed term — typically two to seven years for most business assets. Payments are fixed and predictable. Because you will eventually own the asset, it sits on your balance sheet as both an asset and a corresponding liability from day one, which affects your gearing ratios but also means you can claim capital allowances.
For SMEs eligible for the full expensing regime (100% first-year allowance on qualifying plant and machinery), hire purchase is particularly attractive. In the tax year of purchase, you can potentially write off the entire cost against profits, creating an immediate tax saving that partially offsets the total borrowing cost.
A finance lease is a rental agreement that covers most or all of an asset’s useful economic life without ever transferring legal ownership. The lender buys the asset and leases it to you for a fixed primary period — typically three to seven years — during which you pay regular rentals. The rentals are set to recover most of the asset’s cost, but a residual value is retained by the lender.
At the end of the primary term, you have options: return the asset, sell it on the lender’s behalf (keeping the bulk of the proceeds), or enter a secondary rental period at a much reduced (peppercorn) rate. You never take legal title. Because the lender retains residual value risk in the structure, your monthly payments are lower than they would be under hire purchase for the same asset — you are not paying to fund the entire cost.
Lease rentals are treated as a business expense for tax purposes, making them fully deductible against profit. This is particularly valuable for assets where capital allowances are restricted — most notably cars, where the annual allowance is capped at 6% or 18% depending on emissions, rather than the 100% available under full expensing for other plant and machinery.
Example: £80,000 commercial vehicle, 5-year term
Under hire purchase at a flat rate of 4.5% (APR approximately 8.7%), monthly payments on a 10% deposit (£8,000) would be approximately £1,517 per month. Over 60 months you pay £91,020 plus the £8,000 deposit — total outlay £99,020. At the end, you own the vehicle outright.
Under a finance lease for the same vehicle with a £20,000 residual value retained by the lender, monthly rentals might be approximately £1,180 — a saving of £337 per month. Over 60 months, rentals total £70,800. However, you do not own the vehicle at the end, and if you want to continue using it you’ll enter a secondary period. On a purely cash-flow basis the lease is cheaper month to month; on a total cost-of-ownership basis, it depends on what the vehicle is worth at the end of the term.
Tax impact: An SME claiming full expensing on the £80,000 van under hire purchase saves 25% corporation tax on £80,000 in year one — £20,000. This tax benefit significantly reduces the effective cost of ownership, which is why hire purchase often wins for qualifying assets when the tax position is factored in.
You’re buying specialist machinery that will last 10-15 years and has strong residual value. Hire purchase is the better choice. You’ll own an asset that retains value, you can claim capital allowances in full, and you have no restrictions on modification or disposal. The higher monthly payments reflect that you’re building equity in the asset.
You need a fleet of company cars and want to refresh them every three to four years. Finance lease — or its close relative, contract hire — is the standard answer. Capital allowances on cars are restricted, lease rentals are fully deductible, and at the end of the primary term you simply hand the vehicles back and take new ones. No residual value risk, no disposal headache.
You’re an SME with tight monthly cash flow and need to keep payments as low as possible. Finance lease will give you lower monthly outgoings because the residual value reduces the amount you’re funding. If cash flow is the binding constraint and ownership is secondary, finance lease wins on affordability.
You want to use the asset as security for future borrowing or have freedom to modify it. Hire purchase gives you legal ownership and freedom from lender restrictions. Once you’ve made the final payment, the asset is yours to use, modify, sell, or pledge as security as you see fit.
The hire purchase versus finance lease decision hinges on three questions: do you want to own the asset, what are the tax implications for your specific business, and how important is monthly cash flow versus total cost of ownership? For most plant, machinery, and commercial vehicles where full expensing applies, hire purchase tends to win on total after-tax cost. For cars and fast-depreciating technology, the tax efficiency of lease rentals tips the balance towards a finance lease. Always model the numbers with your accountant before signing — the difference in after-tax cost can be significant.
| Feature | Hire Purchase | Finance Lease |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership at end | Yes — title passes on final payment | No — asset returns to lender or secondary period begins |
| Monthly cost | Higher — full asset cost funded | Lower — residual retained by lender |
| Tax treatment | Capital allowances (plant: full expensing) | Lease rentals tax-deductible as revenue |
| Balance sheet | Asset and liability on balance sheet | On balance sheet under IFRS 16; off-balance-sheet for some SMEs |
| Asset risk | You bear depreciation and residual risk | Shared or retained by lender depending on structure |
| Best for cars | Less efficient — limited capital allowances on cars | More efficient — full rental deduction |
| Asset modification | No restrictions once you own it | Lender consent usually required |
| Typical deposit | 10-20% of asset value | 3 months advance rentals or low deposit |
Rule of thumb: if you want to own the asset and it qualifies for full expensing or a strong capital allowances claim, hire purchase usually wins on total cost and tax. If the asset depreciates quickly (cars, IT equipment), you don't need ownership, or lower monthly payments are the priority, finance lease is likely the better fit. Always model both scenarios with your accountant before committing.
No credit check. Compare rates from 200+ lenders.
Check Eligibility →